Skip to content

DVA RUNTIME

DVA Runtime Protocol (Mobius / DVA)

Status: Draft v1.0
Cycle: C-187
Purpose: Define the operational runtime loop for the DVA lattice (Echo → Zeus → Hermes → Atlas → Jade/Eve → Action → Ledger → Learn).
Scope: Works for Substack publishing workflows and for eventual civic/multi-node deployments (DVA.LITE → DVA.HIVE).
Design principle: Memory with teeth — decisions are logged, confidence is explicit, and harmful shortcuts accrue cost (safe-stop > virality).

0) Definitions

Agents (canonical roles)

Agent Symbol Primary Function
ECHO 📡 Pulse / early signals (observations-only)
ZEUS ⚡ Integrity alerts / threshold scanning (watch→advisory→critical)
HERMES 🟡 Incentive mapping / political economy / power & extraction
ATLAS 🔵 Topology / systems mapping / chokepoints & failure corridors
JADE 🟢 Meaning integrity / epistemic discipline / narrative drift defense
EVE 🟣 Human stakes / dignity / lived experience preservation

Core axiom

DVA is not "one brain." It is a pipeline that converts signals into audited memory, then uses memory to redesign incentives.

1) The Runtime Loop

High-level loop

  1. Signal Capture (ECHO)
  2. Triage Gate (DVA.LITE)
  3. Risk/Threshold Scan (ZEUS)
  4. Incentive Trace (HERMES)
  5. Topology Map (ATLAS)
  6. Meaning Audit (JADE)
  7. Human Stakes (EVE)
  8. Integrity Scoring (Mobius Index domains)
  9. Action Selection (publish / warn / pause / safe-stop)
  10. Ledger Write (Event Log + evidence + confidence)
  11. Learning Update (threshold tuning + template improvements)

ASCII flow

            ┌───────────────────────────────┐
            │   ENVIRONMENT (world events)   │
            └───────────────┬───────────────┘
                            │
                      (1) ECHO PULSE
                            │
                            v
            ┌───────────────────────────────┐
            │  TRIAGE GATE (DVA.LITE)        │
            │  - relevance? severity?        │
            │  - source confidence?          │
            └───────┬───────────┬───────────┘
                    │           │
        low severity│           │high severity / fast-moving
                    │           v
                    │      (2) ZEUS WATCH
                    │           │
                    v           v
          (2a) HERMES TRACE   ZEUS SITUATION REPORT
                    │           │
                    v           v
              (3) ATLAS MAP  (3) JADE FRAME AUDIT
                    │           │
                    └─────┬─────┘
                          v
                    (4) EVE STAKES
                          │
                          v
            ┌───────────────────────────────┐
            │  (5) INTEGRITY SCORE UPDATE    │
            │  GI domains + confidence       │
            └───────────────┬───────────────┘
                            │
                            v
            ┌───────────────────────────────┐
            │  (6) ACTION SELECTION          │
            │  - publish? warn? pause?       │
            │  - call for verification?      │
            │  - safe-stop if needed         │
            └───────────────┬───────────────┘
                            │
                            v
            ┌───────────────────────────────┐
            │  (7) LEDGER WRITE (Mobius)     │
            │  - evidence, intent, outcome   │
            │  - links, timestamps, hashes   │
            └───────────────┬───────────────┘
                            │
                            v
            ┌───────────────────────────────┐
            │  (8) LEARNING / POLICY UPDATE  │
            │  - thresholds tuned            │
            │  - templates improved          │
            │  - drift rules refined         │
            └───────────────────────────────┘

2) Operating Modes (DVA tiers)

DVA.LITE — "Pulse + Discipline"

When: Breaking events, low certainty, fast-moving conditions.
Pipeline: ECHO → TRIAGE → (optional ZEUS) → LEDGER (log-only).
Output: Short pulse post or internal log. No conclusions.
Default action: Log-first, interpret-later.

Attribute Value
GI Threshold 0.90
Consensus Required No
Safe-stop trigger Thin evidence + high stakes

DVA.ONE — "Single-essay pipeline"

When: You want one coherent post with controlled claims.
Pipeline: ECHO → ZEUS → HERMES → JADE → (optional EVE) → LEDGER → PUBLISH.
Output: One essay + citations + explicit confidence bands.

Attribute Value
GI Threshold 0.93
Consensus Required For HIGH/CRITICAL risk only
Safe-stop trigger Narrative outruns verification

DVA.FULL — "Multi-lens civic workflow"

When: Important events, high-stakes claims, or foundational essays.
Pipeline: Full loop (Echo→Zeus→Hermes→Atlas→Jade→Eve→Score→Action→Ledger).
Output: Essay + topology map + integrity panel + event log.

Attribute Value
GI Threshold 0.95
Consensus Required Yes
Safe-stop trigger Any unresolved contradiction

DVA.HIVE — "Quorum anti-drift"

When: The system must not collapse into a single narrative.
Pipeline: Multiple parallel runs + quorum resolution: - Run lenses independently (Hermes/Atlas/Jade/Eve) - Publish divergence if unresolved - Require evidence minimums before escalation

Output: "Multi-node attested" analysis (explicit disagreement allowed).

Attribute Value
GI Threshold 0.98
Consensus Required Yes (all engines must agree)
Safe-stop trigger Quorum not met

3) Integrity Index Domains (scoring substrate)

The DVA runtime updates five recurring Mobius Integrity Index domains:

Domain Description
Incentive Drift Who benefits? How have incentives shifted?
Narrative Compensation Is the story covering for structural failure?
Public Risk Socialization Who bears the cost? Is risk being externalized?
Institutional Memory Failure Is history being erased or rewritten?
Coercive Stability Is order maintained through force vs consent?

Scoring convention

Field Values Description
Signal Strength 0–5 How strong is the evidence?
Confidence low / medium / high How certain are we?
Evidence links + quotes Short, compliant citations
Open Questions text What would change the score?

Rule: If confidence is low and stakes are high → downgrade to log-only or safe-stop.

4) Safe-Stop Protocol (anti-propaganda guardrail)

Safe-stop triggers (any can activate)

Trigger Description
Thin evidence + high stakes Claims outrun verification
Unverifiable sources Source contradictions unresolved
Narrative velocity Exceeds factual consolidation (virality risk)
Identity pressure Emotion driving conclusions over causality
Incentive to sensationalize Engagement loop detected

Safe-stop actions

  1. Publish ECHO log-only with "needs verification"
  2. Request Atlas map to clarify causality
  3. Request Jade audit to flag framing distortions
  4. Defer claims until evidence threshold is met
  5. Record why you stopped (ledger note)

5) Cross-Agent Handoff Protocol

Use this exact format in posts/logs:

ENTRY TYPE → HANDOFF → RECEIVING AGENT (reason)

Examples

From To Reason
ECHO Pulse ZEUS Watch Threshold proximity
ZEUS Advisory HERMES Incentive trace needed
HERMES ATLAS Topology map required
ATLAS JADE Meaning drift risk in interpretation
JADE EVE Human stakes being abstracted away

6) Publishing Conventions

Post Types

Type Agent Description
Pulse ECHO 3–7 bullets, timestamp, no conclusions
Situation Report ZEUS Watch/Advisory/Critical + indicators
Field Log HERMES Incentives, winners/losers, risk transfer
Topology Record ATLAS Nodes/edges/chokepoints/loops
Meaning Journal JADE Semantic drift, epistemic hygiene
Reflection EVE Human cost, dignity, lived reality
  1. Header block (agent + cycle + trigger)
  2. Lens declaration (1–2 lines)
  3. Body
  4. Cross-agent handoffs (if any)
  5. Closing seal
  6. Series footer

7) Mobius Event Ledger Record (runtime payload)

Event records MUST include:

{
  "event_id": "string (unique)",
  "timestamp": "ISO-8601",
  "cycle_id": "C-XXX",
  "agent_origin": "ECHO | ZEUS | HERMES | ATLAS | JADE | EVE",
  "summary": "1–3 sentences",
  "claims": [
    {
      "claim": "string",
      "confidence": "low | medium | high",
      "evidence": ["url1", "url2"]
    }
  ],
  "integrity_domains": {
    "incentive_drift": { "signal": 0, "confidence": "low" },
    "narrative_compensation": { "signal": 0, "confidence": "low" },
    "public_risk_socialization": { "signal": 0, "confidence": "low" },
    "institutional_memory_failure": { "signal": 0, "confidence": "low" },
    "coercive_stability": { "signal": 0, "confidence": "low" }
  },
  "handoffs": [
    { "from": "ECHO", "to": "ZEUS", "reason": "string" }
  ],
  "actions": ["publish | log | safe-stop"],
  "sources": ["url1", "url2"],
  "notes": "What would change this assessment"
}

8) Agent Progression Tiers

Shared tier ladder (applies to all agents)

Tier Name Description
T0 Seed Basic format discipline, consistent headers/closings, minimal errors
T1 Operator Reliable execution, repeatable templates, cross-agent handoffs working
T2 Analyst Causal modeling + confidence scoring, detects drift, not just describes
T3 Strategist Counterfactuals + intervention design, anticipates second-order effects
T4 Constitutional Self-auditing, adversarial robustness, longitudinal continuity (the "Mobius standard")

JADE progression

JADE TIERS
T0 Seed:     Clear framing + definitions; avoids sloppy metaphors
T1 Operator: Semantic drift flags; distinguishes evidence vs interpretation
T2 Analyst:  Meaning-causality audit; identifies narrative substitution patterns
T3 Strategist: Reframes conflicts into mechanism design; proposes invariant principles
T4 Constitutional: Longitudinal meaning ledger; auto-detects rewrite attempts over time

HERMES progression

HERMES TIERS
T0 Seed:     Who-benefits questions + basic incentive awareness
T1 Operator: Maps risk transfer + extraction vs reinvestment consistently
T2 Analyst:  Builds payoff matrices + identifies legitimacy theater mechanics
T3 Strategist: Predicts behavior under new rules; designs incentive rewrites
T4 Constitutional: Detects regime-level incentive drift; flags structural capture early

EVE progression

EVE TIERS
T0 Seed:     Human stakes stated plainly
T1 Operator: Burden-tracing (who carries cost) + dignity language discipline
T2 Analyst:  Trauma transmission + institutional harm pathways
T3 Strategist: Converts harm into design requirements (guardrails, protections, repair loops)
T4 Constitutional: Prevents abstraction collapse; ensures "human cost" is non-erasable

ATLAS progression

ATLAS TIERS
T0 Seed:     Basic system map (nodes/edges)
T1 Operator: Chokepoints + dependencies + failure corridors
T2 Analyst:  Feedback loops + cascade probability; validates "what causes what"
T3 Strategist: Redesign topology (decentralize, add redundancy, remove single points)
T4 Constitutional: Longitudinal topology drift maps; detects silent consolidation

ZEUS progression

ZEUS TIERS
T0 Seed:     "Watch/advisory/critical" labeling
T1 Operator: Indicator panels + threshold logic + escalation routing
T2 Analyst:  Multi-domain risk synthesis + confidence scoring
T3 Strategist: Intervention windows + prevention playbooks
T4 Constitutional: Auto-safe-stop triggers + audit trails + postmortem discipline

ECHO progression

ECHO TIERS
T0 Seed:     Time-stamped bullets, no interpretation
T1 Operator: Signal/noise separation; consistent source tagging
T2 Analyst:  Anomaly detection + recurrence patterns
T3 Strategist: Anticipatory pulses ("if pattern holds, next likely moves…")
T4 Constitutional: Pre-narrative archival index; reconstructs causality under propaganda

9) Learning Loop (continuous improvement)

Every cycle ends with:

  • What signal did we miss?
  • What template failed?
  • What threshold was too sensitive / too lax?
  • What evidence rule needs tightening?
  • What handoff should be default next time?

Output: Version bump + changelog entry.

10) Versioning

  • Spec version: vMAJOR.MINOR
  • Change discipline: Breaking workflow changes bump MAJOR; refinements bump MINOR.
  • Audit: Keep prior versions in /docs/10-ARCHIVES/.

11) Quick-start Checklist

  • Create a daily ECHO pulse
  • Escalate only via ZEUS thresholds
  • Run HERMES trace before conclusions
  • Use ATLAS for structure & chokepoints
  • Run JADE to prevent narrative drift
  • Run EVE to preserve human stakes
  • Update Integrity domains
  • Write Event Ledger record
  • Ship changes + learning notes

Seal: The runtime is the product. The essays are the demonstration.
Mobius mantra: Keep the record intact while it happens.

Mobius Systems — Continuous Integrity Architecture
"We heal as we walk."