ZEUS DISPUTE DISPOSITIONS ZEUS Dispute Dispositions — C-374 Cycle: C-374Agent: ZEUS (Lane C)Ledger ID: mobius:substrate:vault-canon-witness-c374Witnessed at: 2026-07-16T23:30:00Z (UTC)Search scope: mobius-civic-ai-terminal git history (zeus: verification disputed · C-374); Mobius-Substrate (no matching commit subjects)
Enumeration SHA Timestamp (UTC) Repo Files 948ec336e90cd7330473d98e38068423cc08726f2026-07-16T06:02:30Z mobius-civic-ai-terminal docs/catalog/zeus/2026-07-16T06-02-10Z-verification.json 59875437e9f5c4b95c001b4d6c6159224b5ef0b72026-07-16T12:02:28Z mobius-civic-ai-terminal docs/catalog/zeus/2026-07-16T12-02-10Z-verification.json
Count: 2 commits found (handoff cited ≥3 — third not located in either repo; may reflect pending writer run or alternate branch).
Per-commit dispositions 948ec336 — 2026-07-16T06:02:30Z Field Value Claim disputed Production integrity posture for C-374: GI layer alignment, KV key health flags, vault quorum path Evidence reviewed 2026-07-16T06-02-10Z-verification.json — verification_status: disputed, gi_verified: false Key findings Quadruple GI divergence (ATLAS 0.76 cached vs integrity-status 0.82 vs micro 0.907 vs quorum 0.82); persistent kv_keys_ok=false; latest_seal_id: null; POST /api/vault/attest → 404 Disposition Expected pre-recovery state — disputes reflect known Gate G3/G5 gaps and undeployed vault attest route, not a false alarm. Findings remain active until Lane B capture and C-298 route deploy.
59875437 — 2026-07-16T12:02:28Z Field Value Claim disputed Same production surface; afternoon pass after GI degradation Evidence reviewed 2026-07-16T12-02-10Z-verification.json — integrity-status GI dropped to 0.64 yellow/stressed (from 0.82 at 06:02Z pass) Key findings gi_layer_alignment: fail; integrity_freshness: fail (freshness=0.3); themis-govtrack regressed to error; tripwire resolved; sustain_eligible recovered Disposition Stale witness / expected pre-recovery state — afternoon degradation is a real signal (not closed as noise), but root cause is unresolved production integrity freshness + instrument errors, not disputed canon content. Escalation: custodian should correlate with vault/KV health (Lane B), not dismiss. Not unresolved contradiction.
Standing-rule proposal (custodian read) No cycle should close with undispositioned zeus: verification disputed · C-{cycle} commits in the catalog trail. Proposed WITNESS_PROTOCOL.md amendment (one bullet, v1.0.x): "ZEUS verification_status: disputed catalog commits require a disposition record (false positive / stale witness / expected pre-recovery / superseded / escalated contradiction) before cycle close; undispositioned disputes block canon-export intents."
Witness summary Metric Value Commits enumerated 2 False positives 0 Escalated contradictions 0 Expected pre-recovery / stale 2
Restraint row ZEUS catalog commits: NOT rewritten Production endpoints: NOT modified Disputes closed as "noise": 0 July 16, 2026 22:41:57 July 16, 2026 22:41:57