Skip to content

ZEUS DISPUTE DISPOSITIONS

ZEUS Dispute Dispositions — C-375

Cycle: C-375
Agent: ZEUS (Lane C)
Ledger ID: mobius:substrate:renderers-and-archaeology-c375
Witnessed at: 2026-07-17T22:16:00Z (UTC) — refreshed post Gate G3 merge (#400) + vault/status verify (#627)
Search scope: mobius-civic-ai-terminal git history (zeus: verification disputed · C-375); Mobius-Substrate (no matching commit subjects)

Cycle context (updated)

Event SHA / ref Relevance
C-375 daily state sync cbe6daeded70f16c555e43e26b90e8ea237e2e03 Writer advanced C-374 → C-375
OAA Charter §7 merged Substrate #397 (4235a680) Lane A canon complete
Workflow archaeology merged Substrate #398 (bf500049) Lane B B1 complete
Gate G3 capture merged Substrate #400 (566c62d1) 125 collisions witnessed @ run 29592258693
Vault status fix merged Terminal #627 /api/vault/status HTTP 200 post-deploy
Post-deploy witness Substrate #401 (pending) / vault-status-2026-07-17T221206Z.json Closes kv_timeout verification row
Track R receipt draft RECONCILIATION_RECEIPT_BLOCK_001_PROPOSED.md First reconciliation receipt (block 1)

Enumeration

SHA Timestamp (UTC) Repo Files
13b24f391329d9e22bfc562bbebcbeff872719b4 2026-07-17T06:02:35Z mobius-civic-ai-terminal docs/catalog/zeus/2026-07-17T06-02-11Z-verification.json
afeacec3c419a361b5a11e46d4bee368c15cf369 2026-07-17T12:03:27Z mobius-civic-ai-terminal docs/catalog/zeus/2026-07-17T12-03-10Z-verification.json
1c94f609632ca75cee32e5918119ffee9957c356 2026-07-17T18:02:42Z mobius-civic-ai-terminal docs/catalog/zeus/2026-07-17T18-02-19Z-verification.json

Count: 3 commits found (third located on refresh scan).

Per-commit dispositions

13b24f39 — 2026-07-17T06:02:35Z (morning pass)

Field Value
Claim disputed Production integrity posture at C-375 open: GI layer alignment, KV flags, vault quorum path, instrument health
Evidence reviewed 2026-07-17T06-02-11Z-verification.json — verification_status: disputed, gi_verified: false
Key findings Quadruple GI divergence; kv_keys_ok=false; micro_operator_cycle_divergence; integrity_freshness=0.3; POST /api/vault/attest → 404; latest_seal_id: null
Disposition SUPERSEDED_BY_VERIFIED_REF — Gate G3 capture (#400, run 29592258693) now provides timestamped collision + lineage witness for production vault state. Morning GI divergence superseded for witness purposes by afternoon alignment and Gate G3 artifact.
Secondary label EXPECTED_PRE_MERGE_STATE — predates Substrate #397/#398 merge

afeacec3 — 2026-07-17T12:03:27Z (afternoon pass)

Field Value
Claim disputed Same production surface after GI recovery; post–Lane A/B merge window
Evidence reviewed 2026-07-17T12-03-10Z-verification.json — verification_status: disputed, gi_verified: true
Key findings GI layers aligned at 0.82; integrity freshness improved; persistent instrument/tripwire flags; POST /api/vault/attest → 404; latest_seal_id: null
Disposition SUPERSEDED_BY_VERIFIED_REF — afternoon pass partially superseded by Gate G3 artifact (collision-pairs-2026-07-17T152857Z.json, lineage-audit-2026-07-17T152854Z.json). Collision count 125 now verified, not merely disputed.
Secondary label STALE_WITNESS — "capture blocked" language in disposition v1 is stale; Gate G3 capture completed 2026-07-17T16:08Z

1c94f609 — 2026-07-17T18:02:42Z (evening pass)

Field Value
Claim disputed Post–Gate G3 merge window; GI verified via kv-live; persistent anomaly flags
Evidence reviewed 2026-07-17T18-02-19Z-verification.json — verification_status: disputed, gi_verified: true, gi_source: kv-live
Key findings Persistent kv_keys_ok_false, micro_operator_cycle_divergence, tripwire_active, sustain_eligible_false; POST /api/vault/attest → 404; latest_seal_id: null; block 361 candidate at 100%; hermes-arxiv resolved
Disposition STALE_WITNESS — instrument/tripwire/micro-lag signals remain operational debt but collision state is now canon-witnessed at 125 pairs. Dispute does not contradict renderer charter or Gate G3 artifact.
Secondary label EXPECTED_PRE_MERGE_STATE — vault attest 404 and latest_seal_id: null remain open; not closed by disposition

Classification summary

Label Count SHAs
SUPERSEDED_BY_VERIFIED_REF 2 13b24f39, afeacec3
STALE_WITNESS 3 13b24f39, afeacec3, 1c94f609
EXPECTED_PRE_MERGE_STATE 3 13b24f39, afeacec3, 1c94f609
FALSE_POSITIVE 0 —
UNRESOLVED_CONTRADICTION 0 —

Active signals (not closed by this disposition)

Disposition classifies dispute commits; it does not clear production debt or authorize reconciliation apply:

  1. 125 hash-divergent collision pairs — witnessed stable; Track R reconciliation receipts required (block 1 proposed).
  2. 4 lineage components — component-level quarantine policy pending receipt review.
  3. C-298 route — POST /api/vault/attest returns 404 on deployed Terminal surface.
  4. latest_seal_id: null — pointer gap persists (witnessed in Gate G3 + post-deploy vault/status).
  5. Instrument health — tripwire, micro cycle lag, sustain flags remain open.
  6. Workflow archaeology B2 — four custodian workflow decisions open.

Resolved since v1 disposition:

  • Gate G3 capture blocked → COMPLETE (Substrate #400)
  • /api/vault/status kv_timeout → RESOLVED (Terminal #627)

Witness summary

Metric Value
Commits enumerated 3
False positives 0
Unresolved contradictions 0
Superseded by Gate G3 verified ref 2
Canon integrity impact None — disputes are production-witness signals, not renderer-charter conflicts

Restraint row

  • ZEUS catalog commits: NOT rewritten
  • Production endpoints: NOT modified
  • Disputes closed as "noise": 0
  • Reconciliation apply: NOT authorized by this disposition
  • Renderer implementation: NOT authorized by this disposition