C 379 AUDIT live github review

C-379 Audit — Live GitHub Review¶

Captured: 2026-07-21T18:56Z (UTC) — partially superseded by C-379_REAUDIT_infrastructure-recovery-advanced.md (2026-07-21T23:17Z)
Verdict: OPEN — ACTIVE / FEDERATION DRIFT RECOVERY IN PROGRESS (banner superseded)
Banner: C-379 OPEN — FEDERATION DRIFT RECOVERY / ZEUS DISPUTED → see re-audit: INFRASTRUCTURE RECOVERY ADVANCED / DURABILITY + ZEUS VERIFICATION PENDING

C-379 is not a Reserve Block reconciliation cycle first. It is a federation-wide witness and infrastructure drift cycle: scan five surfaces, close stale incidents, identify live mismatches, correct reproducible ones.

1. Cycle writer — GREEN¶

Deterministic writer advanced to C-379 (canon: C-379 daily state sync [skip ci]) with scoped-writer declaration (allowed paths only; no attested values invented). C-379 journal exists and records federation scan as opener.

2. Federation scan (#410) — PASS¶

Substrate #410 merged. Purpose: live scan → Witness Table → 20 optimization items → close stale incidents → escalate live drift.

Witness Protocol exemplar (canon lag retraction):

Stage	Claim
Initial	Canon lag = 360 − 194
Codex challenge	Counting models differ (`seals_count` vs `MANIFEST.total_blocks`)
Verdict	FALSE / RETRACTED
Replacement	Canon lag UNVERIFIED until deduplicated hot count audited

C-376 truth-surface doctrine survived into C-379 — no regression to "360 canonical Reserve Blocks."

3. Reserve Block state¶

Metric	Value
Cold canon MANIFEST	194 blocks (2026-07-12)
Raw Vault records (`seals_count`)	360
Collision pairs	125
Canonical current count	UNRESOLVED
Track R reconciliation	STILL REQUIRED

Do not subtract raw seals_count from MANIFEST.total_blocks. See C368-PR7.

4. MIC wallet (item 6) — PARTIAL CLOSEOUT¶

Phase	Status
Diagnostic (#94)	✅ Merged
Config (#95, #96)	✅ Merged
Connectivity `/health` witness	✅ `db_ok:true` @ 2026-07-21T22:29:11Z
Fail-closed disk policy (#98)	✅ merged
Disk blueprint (#99)	✅ merged
Starter + `ismount` (#100)	✅ merged
Federation disk plans (#101)	✅ merged
Disk + mount witness	✅ `disk_mounted:true` @ 2026-07-21T23:09:47Z
Durability: write survives redeploy	⏳ BLOCKING

Codex P1: /health cannot alone certify persistent storage. Full item 6 closeout requires redeploy-survival test. See re-audit.

5. ZEUS verification — DISPUTED¶

Fresh ZEUS record for C-379: verification_status: disputed. Cycle is not broken; several surfaces agree:

Surface	Value
GI source	KV
ATLAS GI	0.81
integrity-status GI	0.81 (audit); 0.90 live @ 2026-07-21T18:56Z
Quorum	5/5
EPICON candidates	0
Tripwire	resolved
Sustain eligible	true

Persistent inconsistencies:

Micro composite GI 0.902 (ZEUS) vs operator 0.81 — Δ +0.092
Operator cycle C-379 vs micro cycle C-306
kv_keys.ok = true but kv_keys_ok = false (semantic contradiction)

6. Micro layer — STALE / NON-OPERATOR-AUTHORITATIVE¶

Live probe @ 2026-07-21T18:56Z:

Surface	Cycle	GI
`/api/integrity-status`	C-379	0.90
`/api/signals/micro`	C-306	0.896

Witness classification: Micro GI 0.896 is not necessarily mathematically false — it is STALE relative to operator cycle C-379. Value may be internally valid but temporally misaligned.

→ Backlog item 21 (P1): propagate current cycle to micro signal layer.

7. `kv_keys_ok` contradiction¶

ZEUS flags: kv_keys.ok = true, seed_result = 200 OK, but kv_keys_ok = false, kv_keys_all_ok = false.

Two derivation paths for the same concept — witnesses disagree.

Recommended invariant: one authoritative KV-health resolver; all renderers consume same verdict.

→ Backlog item 22 (P1): unify KV health resolver / disposition.

8. EPICON bot FAIL on #410 — STALE / SUPERSEDED¶

Historic EPICON-02 FAIL comment during PR evolution (intent header missing on earlier revision). Final merged PR body contains valid intent block.

Claim	Verdict
Final PR body lacks EPICON	STALE
Historic bot FAIL	SUPERSEDED — disposition should be recorded, not deleted

→ Backlog item 23 (P2): ZEUS / bot dispute disposition workflow for superseded CI comments.

9. Status board¶

Area	Status
Cycle writer	GREEN
C-379 journal	GREEN (updated post-audit)
Federation scan	MERGED
Witness table	MERGED
20-item backlog	ACTIVE (+ extensions 21–23)
Identity service	HEALTHY (C-379 witness)
MIC wallet connectivity	GREEN (`db_ok:true` @ 22:29Z; `disk_mounted:true` @ 23:09Z)
MIC wallet code/blueprint recovery	GREEN (#98–#101 merged)
MIC wallet durability (redeploy-survival)	BLOCKING — item 6 partial closeout
Reserve Block raw/canon semantics	CORRECTED
Canonical RB count	UNRESOLVED
Track R	STILL OPEN
GI operator surfaces	ALIGNED (~0.81–0.90)
Micro GI layer	STALE (C-306)
KV health flags	CONTRADICTORY
Quorum	5/5
EPICON candidates	0
ZEUS cycle verification	DISPUTED

10. Priority order¶

P0/P1  Wallet durability — write → redeploy → read same value (item 6 blocking)
P1     Micro cycle C-306 → restore C-379 temporal alignment (item 21)
P1     kv_keys.ok vs kv_keys_ok → unify resolver (item 22)
P1     ZEUS dispute disposition → classify persistent/transient/resolved (item 23)

       Track R / Reserve Block reconciliation — continues independently

Final verdict¶

C-379 remains OPEN.

C-379 — Federation Witness Sweep: stale incidents closed, wallet drift identified and patched, production acceptance pending; micro/operator cycle divergence remains active.

The cycle demonstrates Witness Protocol behavior end-to-end: cold-start hypothesis → DNS evidence → dashboard witness → repo hardening → redeploy hypothesis test pending.

"We heal as we walk." — Mobius Systems

C 379 AUDIT live github review